we see the world ​​in ben-day dots
  • HOME
  • About
  • Comic Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • Competitions
  • Contributors
  • Contact us

The Punisher: 'Return To Big Nothing' Retrospective.  Part 1.

30/4/2021

0 Comments

 
by Dave Scrimgeour and Kevin McCluskey
Picture

Picture

Writer- Steven Grant
​Penciller- Mike Zeck
Inker- John Beatty
Letterer- Ken Bruzenak
Colourists- Mike Zeck
                  Ian Tetrault
                  Phil Zimmerman
Designer- Robbin Brosterman
Editor- Margaret Clark
Consulting Editor- Carl Potts
Editor In Chief- Archie Goodwin


synopsis

Frank finds himself caught in the midst of an arms deal in the middle of the Nevada desert, which inadvertently leads him back to a figure from his distant past, and presents him with an opportunity to avenge some losses.


​Dave
So, ‘Return to Big Nothing,’ and a return to Steve Grant and Mike Zeck for us.  When was this published?


Kev
It was either 1988 or 1989.  My copy is a second printing, and it's from 1989, so I reckon it might first have been published in 1988.

​
Dave
The cover is great.  The Punisher is looking mean, and deadly.  The black background intensifies the mood, and also the darkness of this character.  And he's sporting a slight teddy boy haircut to boot.


Kev
Ha, ha!  With the widows peak going on as well.  Yeh, it's a cracking cover.  Frank's looking bodybuilder-big here.  Lots of protein, and very little cardio, I would assume.


Dave
It's always a good start, having an eye catching cover.


Kev
Definitely.  You don't need much more than that image of Frank to sell me on this.  Bit of an unusual font though.  Maybe they were trying to make it look less like a comic book, and more like a proper, grown up book, so to speak.


Dave
I like that the font is not taking over the page.  The image of Punisher says it all really.   It was probably done that way on purpose.


Kev
I would imagine so, yeh.  Do you see this as a direct sequel to 'Circle Of Blood?


Dave
I see it as an unofficial sequel.  It kind-of can be construed as a sequel, I suppose.  Sort of season 2 of a series.  Do you?


Kev
Yeh, I do.  It'd be cool if that, as soon as he was done with Angela on the bridge in 'Circle,' he went almost straight into this within a matter of days, but I reckon there has been a bit more of a passage of time.  As you say, almost like the gap between seasons of a TV show.


Dave
I love the internal narration that we get from Frank at the start of the story, and it is a proper good splash page panel as well.  It gets us right into the thick of it.  Plus, some very deep philosophies from Frank here.  Probably not a good idea to try them out at an open mic night though, might scare the audience a bit.


Kev
Agreed.  I love the narration of the inner monologue, but yeh, not exactly comedy gold, is it?  And is it just me, or has Zeck drawn Frank to look ever so slightly like Dolph Lundgren on that splash page?
PictureThat costume might need a quick wash after this mission, Frank.

​Dave
Good point, I never really picked up on that Lundgren thing.  He does seem a bit different from 'Circle of Blood.'


Kev
Definitely.  There is certainly a feeling of the character having evolved somewhat since 'Circle.'  Or perhaps even devolved.  He seems even more clinical, detached and robotic than he did in the previous outing.


Dave
Straight off the bat, the bad guys have just made a classic 'A-Team' style mistake of locking him in a truck with an arsenal of weapons, or more likely he has snuck in without them seeing but, either way, you know it's not going to end well for them.  I like how the panels pan out a bit from the first page, but Frank is still in darkness.


Kev
I like the way it opens up as well.  Yeah, I got the impression that he had just stowed away in the back of their truck, knowing full well it contained a load of ammo.  Then it cuts to the searing heat and blinding sunlight of the desert.  Is it the Nevada desert?


Dave
Yeah, and it's also good that the story just starts, right in the middle of something.  The artwork is great here, as is the pacing of the story too.  And it's the set up of a scene that usually helps the execution of delivery.


Kev
I like that we're just dropped into the middle of the story as well.  It's a classic writing technique.


Dave
"I am death.  All roads lead to me."


Kev
Death is certainly all over this book, yeh.  Which isn't surprising, really.  Considering our "hero" wears of massive, fuck-off death skull on his upper body.


Dave
It's a heavily armed scenario.


Kev
Yeh, Frank is certainly getting himself well tooled-up before he comes out, all guns blazing.


Dave
And from the looks of it, there are a few players involved, what with the guy hiding behind the rocks and everything.  As the reader, you're kind-of just trying to figure what is happening in the space of the first few pages.  It's setting up that something is definitely about to go down.


Kev
​It's a set-up alright.  In more ways than one.  The story isn't just opening up visually, it's also opening up narratively as well.



Dave
I like the panel of Frank hiding behind the boxes, when the doors are opened to the truck.  "Cambodians..interesting.”  His narrative is so essential to the Punisher.  It adds to his depth, and makes him a more multi-layered character.

Picture
"Guns. Lots of guns."

​Kev
Definitely.  It's a cracking panel, alright.  First person narration within caption boxes is a technique that has fallen out of favour in more modern comics, to the point that it's looked down on, but it literally puts us inside Frank's head here, and the story is all the better for it, I reckon.  It's like an old noir movie, with the PI's voiceover helping to set the scene as well as build the character.  Or Deckard's in that much maligned cut of 'Blade Runner.'  But the less said about that, the better.


Dave
The panel where the FBI guy walks out from behind the rocks waiving his badge, looks like he has just turned up to a party.  "Hi guys.  I'm here," sort of thing.  It works well, as it is drawn like a long distance shot.


Kev
It's an excellent composition from Zeck.  A proper Mexican standoff in the desert.  Like an old western movie.  Or 'Reservoir Dogs.'  Or 'City On Fire,' even.
Picture
"Larry, stop pointing that gun at my fucking dad!"

​​Dave
And while this is happening there is still narrative to show Frank's surprise, "What the hell?"


​Kev
Ha, ha!  Yeh, Frank kind-of stumbles into a bit of a shit-show here.


Dave
In the space of a few pages, the pace of the story has quickly picked up, and we have gone into a full-on shoot out.


Kev
Yeh, Steve Grant is wasting no time, or comic book page real estate here.  Like you said, start in the middle, and boom, right into the action.  Frank shows that he has very little respect for the Feds here, referring to them as "amateurs."


Dave
The pacing is great, I agree.  It suits The Punisher.  Yep, Frank gets a bit philosophical here, before bursting out the truck to engage in an onslaught.
Picture
".....are a British boy band from London consisting of members Sean Conlon, Ritchie Neville, and Scott Robinson."

​Kev
Yep.  Frank's Art Of War philosophy.  And we get an example of his questionable morality, in that, if Frank is stealing guns and money from criminal organisations for his “war,” is he really any better than those he’s dishing out his brand of justice to?


Dave
That's the thing, it's the morally ambiguous world of The Punisher.  One of the things that I liked about the Netflix series, was that they dealt with that, and not all of Frank’s choices would be liked or agreed with.


Kev
No.  And neither they should be really.  Frank is not a "hero."  I'm not even sure he's an "anti-hero" either really.  I mean, I love Frank Castle as a character, but he is not exactly likeable, is he?
 

Dave
He certainly doesn't see himself as a "hero," he is just hellbent on wreaking his own justice on the shit of humanity.  That's where his likeability comes from, doing what the law doesn't do, punishing effectively.  It's that kind-of cathartic thing.  The ethics of it usually come from conflicting characters, and how the readers perceive this type of character.  It's genius, really.


Kev
That's a good point.  It's that release of living vicariously through a character that is willing, and able, to do the things that we either can't, or could never bring ourselves to, do.


Dave
Essentially, that's what it comes down to.


Kev
I like Frank's countdown to the explosives, prematurely, going off.  "Short fuse."  You do have a bit of a short fuse, Frank.  Yes.


Dave
In some ways, with having recently re-watched The Crow, I realise that they are both characters who fully understand their mission.  However, Punisher does have more self doubts at times, like in 'Circle of Blood,' but in this story he seems to be more self assured.  The panel of him shooting two guys at the same time is great, he's just a war machine when he gets going.
Picture
A stroll in the desert, Frank Castle style.

​Kev
Ha, ha!  Yeh.  He's a machine, alright.  This is something that has been drilled into him, his entire adult life.  It's second nature to him.
He does seem more self-assured here, doesn't he?  ​I was thinking that as well.  


Dave
Yeah he does, and the end panel on that page, with him carrying the injured Fed, and the explosion, is a great way to close off that set piece.  Pace wise this story is moving along relentlessly now, with the narrative unfolding as we go.


Kev
Yeh, it's a great opening set-piece.  It's kind-of like the pre-titles scene to a Bond movie, or something.  It's definitely opened with a bang.  Literally.  And here we have the link, not only to the smuggled US Army arms, but also to Frank’s past and the Vietnam War itself, Gorman.  Who doesn’t seem to have aged much at all in the ensuing years, despite his stressful occupation and his stomach ulcer.
Picture
"All those who remember the war, they won't forget what they've seen."

​Dave
Yeah.  I guess Gorman likes his daily moisturising and facial cleanses.  Never let it be said that tough guys don't have a more sensitive side.


Kev
Gorman was metro-sexual before David Beckham made it cool to be metro-sexual.  


Dave
So, when Frank finds out his old CO, Gorman, is involved in this, his first thought is, "Castle knew him," referring to his old self as being a completely different person.


Kev
Yeh, there's definitely a pre-family-being-gunned-down-by-the-mob, Frank Castle, and a post-family-being-gunned-down-by-the-mob, Punisher, isn't there?


Dave
Yeah.  And also, we get the explanation of where the title 'Return To Big Nothing' comes from.


Kev
We do indeed.  I like that "Big Nothing" banner between the two barracks.


Dave
Younger Frank looks like the alpha in the barracks, amongst his fellow soldiers.  Just the way he is positioned in amongst them.  It reminds me of an episode of M*A*S*H*.


Kev
Definitely.  He's the focus in that panel.  Jeez, y'know what, the M*A*S*H* thing never even occurred to me.  Even after all this time, and having read this so often.  Frank's youthful naivety is apparent though, both in his faith in US military superiority, and his prediction that once they get to Saigon they’ll end the war “in a couple of weeks.”


Dave
At this point he just wants to get back to his family life.


Kev
Does he have his family at this point?  I always thought that this was before he met Maria and had kids.  It wouldn't surprise me if I had just wrongly assumed this though.  You know what they say about assumptions, and all that.


Dave
Yeah, he was married, and there was a baby on the way.


Kev
Ah, right.  I completely misunderstood that.  Makes total sense, now that you mention it.


Dave
He also seems quite hot headed, getting straight into it with Gorman and taking a kicking in the process, hence him becoming the title of the story, "Big Nothing."

Kev
Yeh, Frank commits like an impatient, inexperienced fighter here.  Impetuous, charging straight in, winging punches, and he gets whipped as a result.  He seems to be relishing the thought of a rematch now though.  "Gorman.  Good."
Picture
Frank misses with that overhand left, eats a knee and also a kick to the midsection when he's a downed opponent.
Picture
Gorman with the first round TKO over Castle.

​Dave
Yeah sloppy fighting indeed from Frank.  This Punisher reminds me more of the Jon Bernthal version, being that hot headed and impatient at times, especially in the flashback scene.


Kev
That's a good point.  The Bernthal version of the character is like a volcano, constantly waiting to erupt.


Dave
The Punisher's morals have no effect on his ability to do his mission though, once the FED dies, he just assumes his identity.


Kev
Totally.  Even in death, this guy is still useful.  He's still an asset.  Well, for a couple of days at least.  Until the Feds realise he's dead, that is.


Dave
And I've just noticed, he's sporting the '80s' black eyeliner as well.


Kev
Yep.  Gotta rock that sexy '80's guyliner.


Dave
Interesting that in the next page, as we see the technically older looking Gorman, he is actually unnerved by these events.  That is, until he gets the file on exactly who this "clown vigilante" is, then he is grinning like a Cheshire cat.  
Picture
Cracking set of veneers on Gorman. You must get dental cover as an arms and drugs smuggler.

Kev
Other than his hairline, he looks pretty much the same, and like he's still in good shape.  Yeh, I love how Gorman’s concerns about The Punisher dissipate as soon as he realises that The Punisher is, in fact, his old punching bag, Frank Castle.


Dave
When he realises who the Punisher is, Gorman looks like Hannibal from 'The A-Team,' just with a smaller cigar.  He just loves it when a plan comes together.


Kev
Ha, ha.


Dave
The flashbacks doesn't slow down the story at all, it has a great pace of storytelling.


Kev
Yeh, Steve Grant's plotting is excellent here.  It all just clicks into place, and it feels so natural in doing so.  It's pretty seamless.  And Mike Zeck’s and John Beatty’s artwork on these Vietnam flashbacks is tremendous.  It reminds me of Michael Golden’s work on the early issues of ‘The ‘Nam,’ which, of course, was the back-up strip in the previously mentioned Punisher Weekly comic here in the UK.  That's probably why it reminds me of it actually, because they were so linked in my mind at such a formative period in my life.
Picture
"Destruction of men in their prime, whose average age was nineteen. N-n-n-n-nineteen."

​Dave
Yeah I totally forgot about 'The 'Nam' until you mentioned it being in those old Punisher weekly comics.  That was a great comic at the time.


Kev
Yeh, it's something I'd like to go back to and revisit properly at some point.


Dave
Gorman is getting really cocky now, referring to Frank as "Big Nothing," but I like that we already have a more than formidable adversary for The Punisher.  And Frank has been put on point in the flashback here, to add further insult to injury and humiliation.  This lends more depth to the character, giving him a more human and relatable quality.


Kev
Yeh, he's been put on point as a sacrificial lamb really, hasn't he?  Although, he's a bit too good, and it doesn't quite pan out the way Gorman has hoped.


Dave
Jeez that cheeser of a grin needs to wiped off his smug, overly moisturised face.


Kev
Yeh, Gorman's like a L'Oreal For Men poster boy.


Dave
And I bet he thinks he's worth it.


Kev
Ha, ha!


Dave
In that flashback, Frank looks like he's had enough of the war and just wants out of it.


Kev
Yeh, already Frank has gone from being naively optimistic about it, to all too aware of how rotten to the core the whole affair is.


Dave
Gorman should team up with Alaric.  Pair of cheesy bastards.


Kev
God, yeh.  Gorman would've fit right in with The Trust.


Dave
Then, as it switches back to the present, Frank is doing his undercover routine as a FED, but he is clearly walking into a trap.  He doesn't seem to know when these things run too easy, and that something is amiss.


Kev
I'd like to see Frank doing more of this kind of undercover business.  I really enjoy it.  Yeh.  Frank thinks he's one step ahead of Gorman here but, unfortunately for him, it's the other way round.  "There's always them who won't be beat."  I like the fact that Gorman recognises Frank immediately, by his voice though.


Dave
The tide has turned quickly on Frank here, as he has clearly walked into a trap.  But that's what I like about The Punisher, he is fallible, he does make mistakes, and he is probably lucky to still be alive with some of the mistakes he made. 


Kev
​Yeh, he's not BatGod.  He hasn't planned for every eventuality in his head a million times.  He certainly wouldn't be beating any Supermen, that's for sure.  But you're right, that's a good thing.


​
Dave​
I like that panel of Gorman, posing while waiting on Frank, reading the writing on the clipboard.  Poster boy stuff indeed.
Picture
Gorman is like a walking, talking Wellman commercial.

Kev
Ha, ha!  It is a bit of a catalogue pose, isn't it?


Dave
And Gorman proceeds to give The Punisher another beating, whilst enjoying every moment of reminding him of his previous encounter as well.  Is Gorman actually physically bigger than Frank in this scene?  It's hard to tell, as Frank is wearing a jacket.


Kev
He's of equal size, at the very least, yeh.  Although, it's only when his goons jump in that he truly gets the better of Frank.  Which Gorman's quick to chastise them for, despite the fact that he'd already made sure he had a distinct advantage by handcuffing Frank.  I like the use of the empty caption box to illustrate that Frank’s thoughts have stopped suddenly, due to him being K.O.d.


Dave
Yeah, the blank caption is good.  Something tells me a fair fight is not really what Gorman is interested in, more like having the odds stacked in his favour.


Kev
Definitely not.  He doesn't like to make bets that he knows he can't win, that's for sure.  The colours in this book, by Zeck, Ian Tetrault and Phil Zimmerman are superb.  I'm not sure which of the three of them was responsible for the next scene, the one in the desert at night, but the palette is outstanding.  The purples of the light in the desert sky at night are absolutely lovely. 


Dave
Totally, the desert scene colours are superb, the shadows and background colours are excellent, and the story never falters.  It has never gone off on any pointless tangents.  It has stuck to its narrative without fault.


Kev
It's made crystal clear that Frank is still suffering from PTSD here.  He’s constantly having flashbacks and nightmares about his time served in Vietnam.  And that’s without taking into account the fact that he had witnessed his family being mowed down in the crossfire of a gang war in Central Park several years later as well.


Dave
Yeah well, the 'Nam was a big cause of PTSD in soldiers, so technically he has two lots of PTSD to deal with, I suppose.  


Kev
Exactly.  Frank has a lot of issues that he's dealing with.  Or rather, not dealing with.


Dave

While the violence is quite brutal, it has been dealt with without making it gory, so it lends itself to this feel of a tough-as-nails type story.  It's almost done tastefully, if you catch my drift.


Kev
Absolutely, I totally agree with you on the tone.  It's tough, and it's gritty, but it never feels exploitative or gratuitous.  It really does feel like a good '80's action movie.


Dave
And of course you get the token idiot who carelessly flings his matches near an explosive device in the backseat.


Kev
Ha, ha!  There's always one, eh?


Dave
One thing about Frank is, never underestimate his ability to get out of a tricky situation of his own making.  His skill set also saves his own neck a lot of the time.  And don't bad guys know it's never a good idea to leave him unsupervised, for even a short period of time. 


Kev
Yeh, you would've thought that his reputation would have preceded him by this point, wouldn't you?


Dave
I wonder if this was part of Gorman's plan, to not kill him directly.  A kind of a test to see if he would survive this and come back for him.  Gorman seems to like playing games, especially with one Mr. Castle.


Kev
Could be actually, yeh.  I like Frank’s little comment on the American automobile industry, and the quality of its manufacturing in the late ‘80s.  “...., construction’s weak.”  That’ll be why so many Americans were buying Japanese or European, even back then.


Dave
Maybe he was preparing for a guest spot on Top Gear, with these wise points on the state of the automobile industry in America.


Kev
He would've fit right in during the Clarkson, May and Hammond era.


Dave
The panel after the car explosion, of the two kids grinning is good.  They just look like such low level henchmen, straight out of henchman academy.  Then we go back to Frank’s thoughts, as he deems them "amateurs," and points out their mistakes.
PictureYeah, "Nice colours." That's what we said too.

​​Kev
Yeh, they're definitely not the brightest, are they?  Although, I really like the use of the light source of the car explosion on their faces in the colouring.  Again, stellar stuff.  We get Frank’s, Mr. Joshua bit here with him using the flaming car wreckage to cut the ropes on his wrists.  But yeh, his disdain for the sheer incompetence of these low-level criminals is palpable.  He refers to them as “amateurs” on more than one occasion here.  Then again, Frank's referred to almost everyone as "amateurs" all the way through this story so far.


Dave
Right enough, he uses the fire to cut the ropes.  Good thinking though, and of course, he is ignoring the pain at this point.  Furthermore, he has gained another lead from the packet of matches.


Kev
Like I said before, I do like when Frank uses his brain, as well as his brawn and ammo.  He's not a stupid, meat head of a man.


Dave
No, he is tactical and methodical as well.  The last panel on that page is a nice little close up of him, with good use of the shadows.  The artwork has equally matched the written storytelling so far.  "Let them run, I'll be waiting."


Kev
That's a great line to end the scene on, for sure.


Dave
How are you finding re-reading this so far?


Kev
It's always a pleasure going back to look at this one.  Even so soon after reading it again for Max Byrne's 'Mandatory Marvel and DC' podcast.  I always find something in it that occurs to me for the first time, or having discussed it with Max, and now yourself, have something pointed out to me that I had missed, or have a different take on things explained to me that I had always assumed were just a certain way.  What about yourself?  How are you finding it, after all these years?


Dave
I think it's been a cracking story so far.  As I said earlier, the narrative is actually one of the best I have read, in terms of not wasting time unnecessarily.  Also, I like the simplicity of it.  Had this been written nowadays, there would have been about three or four subplots all going on at the same time, which would have dragged it out, but none of that is in there.  The pacing is great as well, as it explodes into the action early and keeps it up at a steady tempo.  So far it's been really good and enjoyable.


(D) & (K)

​Next: Prostitution and Gambling.
Picture
0 Comments

    Back issues

    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • HOME
  • About
  • Comic Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • Competitions
  • Contributors
  • Contact us