we see the world ​​in ben-day dots
  • HOME
  • About
  • Comic Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • Competitions
  • Contributors
  • Contact us

The Spectacular Spider-Man #149 Retrospective- 'What About Carrion?!'

30/4/2019

0 Comments

 
by Dave Scrimgeour & Kevin McCluskey
Picture

Picture

​​Cover Date- April 1989

Price- 50p

Script- Gerry Conway
Art- Sal Buscema
Lettering- Rick Parker
Colour- Bob Sharen
Editor- Jim Salicrup
Editor-In-Chief- Tom DeFalco
Publisher- Marvel Comics


Synopsis

Peter Parker returns to his college studies, just in the nick of time for one of his fellow students to inadvertently turn himself into the latest incarnation of Carrion.  This results in a journey down the rabbit-hole of clones and battles with the past, as Peter's love for Gwen Stacy threatens to undo his marriage to Mary Jane in its infancy.  Oh, and there's a werewolf prowling the streets of Manhattan ripping the Kingpin's goons to pieces as well.  (K)

Dave
Well, we’re nearing the end of the Tombstone saga, as this is the penultimate issue.  I like the cover, it's a good contrast, with the Gothic colours of Carrion and the brightness of the Spidey outfit.  It's another eye catching image.


Kev
Yeh, man.  It's a cool cover.  It's action packed and dynamic.  There's a real sense of movement to it.  I love the depth of field in the graveyard and the overcast, cloudy sky is moody.  I always thought this Gwen Stacey WAS a clone though.


Dave
That Gwen Stacy story just confuses the hell out of me.  It gives 'Twin Peaks' a good run for its money.


Kev
Ha, ha!  Special Agent Peter Parker.  I absolutely love this prologue, opening with Eduardo Lobo in his werewolf form.  The silhouette of him against the full moon is a cracking image as well.  I remember loving this storyline, back when you were buying this and Mike was buying Web, when we were young.  Looking back on it, I think it was the inclusion of the slightly more horror-style elements that excited me about it.  That last panel on that first page is excellent too.
Picture
"I used to be a werewolf but I'm okay nooowww!"
Picture
"Bright eyes. Burning like fire."

​Dave
I do like the first couple of pages.  The artwork is phenomenal.  Plus, I like the Kingpin henchman who is dressed like Frank Nitti.  Nice little touch, especially as 'The Untouchables' was in cinemas in 1987.
PictureDress for the job you want.

​Kev
That's a really good point about the henchman.  That hadn't dawned on me at all.  Especially the potential 'Untouchables' reference.



Dave
He even looks a bit like Billy Drago.


Kev
He really does, as well.


Dave
I would have preferred this issue to follow the Lobo Brothers story instead of the Carrion/Gwen Stacy clone one, if I'm being honest.


Kev
Yeh, I know what you mean.  I much prefer the Lobo Brothers stuff.  The clone saga was just a mess by this point.


Dave
The full page spread shows how far Peter has come in life, yet he's still sitting in a classroom environment.


Kev
Yeh.  It's good to see him back in academia, but I wonder if it feels like a bit of a step back in time to ol' Pete.  I love the smirk on the girls face to his left as he zones-out in the class.


Dave
The blonde guy in the background is the new Flash Thompson-esque type of character for this issue and these times.  Not much has changed, except Pete is older and more than capable of handling himself, but yep, he still is always zoning-out.


Kev
Malcolm McBride is definitely a bit of a Flash Thompson character, yeh.  It's interesting though that Peter is acting towards McBride in a similar way to that which Flash would've acted towards Peter back in high school.  There's an element of role reversal here.  Peter using the girls to get under McBride's skin.  Is Peter essentially the bully here?  Using his experience as well as his intelligence to put down McBride?  Also, Peter being referred to as "old man" by McBride is interesting, considering Peter was always looked upon as being the face of "youth" in the Marvel universe in so many ways.  There's an awareness of the passing of time for Peter since high school.


Dave
Maybe.  Yet Pete still scolds himself for his aggressive behaviour towards McBride.  It's very instinctive of him.  He is used to acting first then reflecting on those actions later, which is something the younger version of him would not necessarily have been able to do.  It really shows how far Peter has grown as a person, that he still has his thinker side to himself, the reflective Peter who can empathise with others, even Malcolm McBride.


Kev
Yeh, you're right.  There's definitely an emotional maturity to Peter by this point.  I love how even the creative team are admitting that this whole clone saga is a confusing, ridiculous, convoluted mess with lines such as, "It never made much sense that my college biology professor would be able to clone a human being from a few cell samples"  and captions like, "One last try to tie it all together, courtesy of..."


Dave
It is a totally messy story.  To the point of trying to follow it is enough to give you a headache, I've got to say.  ​That’s what doesn't make this issue a good read at all, I became detached from the story.  I'm just glad to get to the final chapter of it, by this point.

PictureAh, the joys of being a "mature" student, eh Pete?

​Kev
It really does feel like, editorially, Salicrup was sick of it, as was Conway as the writer and they decided to use this issue as a last ditch attempt to tie it all up.


Dave
It just became far too complicated.  Professor Swan looks like a right character.



Kev
Ha, ha!  He does indeed.  Sal's rendition of him in panel 2 of page 4 is superb.  You get such a sense of personality from it.  He really is an amazing cartoonist.


Dave
I like how Malcolm McBride finds a potion that is still in the container lying underground without a drop spilled.  The villainous look on his face adds a good element to the image though.  It's very horror story-esque.


Kev
Yep.  He's got a good evil grin does Malcolm.  Nice literary joke with the Frankenstein quip on the last panel of page 6 as well.


​Dave

Indeed, it does have a bit of Frankenstein's monster vibe to it, this story.  Tombstone's presence in the Robbie Robertson trial is a fresh element to the next interlude.  He looks so smug on the stand.  Do you remember much about the Joy Mercado character?

PictureLook at that wee face. Like butter wouldn't melt.

Kev
Ha, ha!  Yeh, that look on Tombstone's face, in panel 5 of page 9, he looks like a mischievous little boy.  I remember a little of Mercado from around this time.  I always liked her.  But then again, I really enjoyed all of Conway's supporting cast from the Bugle, with Kate Cushing, Joy Mercado, Gloria Grant etc. etc.  It just makes Peter's world seem more fleshed-out and fully realised to me, more real.  I wonder what all those characters are up to these days?  I also like that Conway is using the University setting to introduce a whole new batch of supporting characters.  It's even more of that soap opera drama stuff that I love.


Dave
Poor Gloria.  Her bubble is about to be burst big time, walking around the office, singing away too.


Kev
Yeh, things are not going to end well for Gloria, are they?  I like the use of the pink background for her, on panel 6 of page 11, to hammer home just how in love she is.  With a werewolf.  
And, unfortunately for Kate Cushing, it seems like she has drawn the short straw, to be the one that has to pop Gloria's bubble.



Picture"Oooh, it's so good, it's so good, it's so good, it's so good."

​Dave
Conway loves to fill his stories with various interludes.


Kev
Oh, definitely.  Conway loves an interlude.  They help to keep all these interweaving plots and subplots bubbling away nicely, I suppose.  


Dave
There has to be a full moon on the interlude 2 opening panel at Empire State University, of course. It's a good, eye catching panel.


Kev
Ah, good point.  The full moon helps sell the reader on the horror elements of the story and also puts us back in mind of the werewolf or werewolves that are now running wild in New York City.


​Dave
And so begins the transformation....into Carrion.


​Kev

Yep, Malcolm McBride certainly didn't last long as a supporting character.  Conway culled him quick smart.


Dave
Then we go back to the real mind melter, the diary of Miles Warren.  I could hardly make out the writing in this.  Probably just as well.


Kev
I agree.  The use of the sepia tones/yellows for the flashback is excellent and the handwritten lettering in the caption boxes for Miles Warren's diary is a sound idea, but that font is a bit of a chore to read, isn't it?


Dave
Yeah.  I get that the diary shows Warren's own handwriting, but it could have been a lot more legible.


Kev
Totally.  It's not exactly an easy read, is it? ​ And Peter really is terrible at preserving his secret identity.  Just changing out in the open.  Illuminated by the full moon.

Picture
Peter Parker's "secret" identity.

Dave
No wonder he keeps getting his identity discovered, carrying on like that.


Kev
M.J. looks sick to the back teeth of hearing Peter bang on about Gwen on page 14, and I can't say I blame her for her fears over Peter's inability, or unwillingness, to move on with his life and leave the past in the past.  There's no competing with ghosts.  They can remain perfect.  You're right though, man, this clone saga stuff is just so convoluted by this point and it's like, in trying to fix it, they're actually just making it even worse.
PictureThe term, "dripping with sarcasm" was made for this.

Dave
Yeah, does anyone actually care who Carrion is anymore?


Kev
To be honest, probably not, no.  I think the character was more a convenient plot device than anything else here, in that essentially, anyone could be Carrion because of the nature of the virus.


Dave
True.  That is a classic Spidey panel of him swinging through the air at night.  You generally get one of these per issue.


Kev
Yeh, you're right.  Buscema always treats us to at least one per issue.


Dave
In saying that,  although we're diminishing Carrion, this is a pretty good rumble between him and Spidey.


Kev
Yeah, I really like that fight sequence between Spidey & Carrion on pages 18 & 19.  Yet more cracking stuff by Sal Buscema.


Dave
The stakes have gone up, as Spidey has to make sure he does not come into direct contact with Carrion's hands.  There are some good action sequences in this fight, with of course, Spidey losing round one.

PictureThat's a couple of lost teeth, right there.

Kev
There's some excellent panels in here and some fantastic choreography as well.  And yeh, the fact that Peter can't let Carrion touch him certainly adds another layer to the tension and the drama in this fight.  I quite like the little catch-up conversation with Spidey and Carrion actually, as neither of them really has a clue as to what's really going on.  Although, Peter is ridiculously bad at protecting his secret identity.  Now this Malcolm McBride version of Carrion knows who he is as well.


Dave
It's a good finale setting, in the graveyard.  It suits the tone of this story and as you say, catches up with the cover.


Kev
Yeh, I wonder how long it took Carrion to copy the pose of the gargoyle on top of the tombstone.


Dave
Haha!  Yeah, he's kind-of adopted a Spidey pose on top of the wall and is almost mimicking the statue next to him.  I like how Spidey calls him "mold mouth" before he gets a chance to fling more death dust at him.


Kev
Ha, ha!  I agree, "Mold-Mouth" is a decent put-down.


Dave
Come to think of it, the gargoyle looks like the Zuul gargoyle in 'Ghostbusters' again.


Kev
Right enough.  Perhaps Sal was a 'Ghostbusters' fan.  This is good work by Buscema on the fight scene in the graveyard.  It's the sort of stuff I just ate up as a youngster, especially that panel of Spidey flying backwards into the tombstone after the flying kick from Carrion.  And the backgrounds are just beautiful too.  The mood and atmosphere they create is just excellent.

Picture
Sal Buscema, ladies and gentlemen. Poetry in motion.

​Dave
It is a great setting to finish off the story.  It all adds to the tone and mood of the piece.  Spidey can't half deliver some good crosses, hooks and uppercuts when he wants to.  This is one of his trademark, close quarter combat fighting techniques, me thinks.
Picture
2.

​Kev
Definitely.  Once again, we see from this fight scene that, if you give him an opening, Spidey can wipe the floor with you.  This is almost a re-run of that fight with Tombstone on the construction site in issue 142.
Picture
6.

​Dave
Yeah, it feels a bit like that.  Also, it shows he has a bit of range in his fighting technique as well.
Picture
Setting him up. Showing patience.

​Kev
Oh, yeh.  He's not just good at web-swinging around his opponents and peppering them with blows from the outside and using distance.   Like you said, he's extremely effective in the pocket as well.
Picture
4.

​Dave
The final panel, when Carrion smashes into the gravestone, is a cracker.  The finishing blow.  Power punch or what?
Picture
K.O.

​Kev
It's superb, isn't it?  That's another Buscema trademark, those power punch panels.  "Sometimes reality is hard to accept.  But get used to it.  When the dream dies, when the nightmare is over ---- reality is all you've got left."  Peter's clearly thinking about Gwen here.


Dave
He probably is, yeah.  I’m assuming it was Miles Warren's gravestone that Carrion was sent flying into.


Kev
It'd certainly be poetic if it was.


Dave
The weather has changed.  And suddenly it's daytime too.  Peter best be careful removing his mask, there could easily be someone else in the vicinity, given his track record for letting his identity get discovered.


Kev
Ha, ha!  You're right.  He should've at least had a look around before he whipped the mask off.  Or maybe just leave it on Pete.  Just to be on the safe side, eh?


Dave

Yep, he still doesn't learn about taking the mask off, does he?


Kev
​Ha, ha!  Nope.  Not at all.  
Come to think of it, why doesn't his spider-sense go off when all these people are seeing him in the costume without the mask on?


Dave

That's what I was wondering earlier.  Some Spider-Sense that is.


Kev
It's a bit hit and miss, isn't it?  Anything to serve the story, I suppose.


Dave
I suppose.  Peter is a man, still burdened heavily by guilt.

​

Kev
He certainly is, but this is a new dawn for Peter, a "brand new day," so to speak.  He's finally reached a point where he's ready to leave his past behind and embrace his future.



Dave
Yeah, but Pete is always going to be a tortured soul though.  The last three panels are quite visually striking, a nice long shot to end the story on and the classic movie-style, "The End" to signify the conclusion of this saga.
Picture
Gwen Stacy No More.

Kev
I agree.  Those last three panels on that bottom tier are great.  They're a nice callback to 'Spider-Man No More' too.  Although, they're perhaps more Spider-Man Forever.


Dave
That bottom row quickly closes this issue and this story off.  I'm pretty sure the whole creative and editorial team were glad of that.  Much like we are.


Kev
Definitely.  I hear what you're saying about the guilt though.  "Responsibility" is shown to be Peter's curse again here, as well as the guilt that often comes with it.  Overall, this is a decent enough issue.  I like it.  It’s a thoroughly enjoyable read.  Particularly considering Conway is traversing the Gwen Stacy clone minefield, which this issue is certainly burdened with.  Plus, I still can't shake the feeling that 'Inferno' has rocked Conway's schedule a bit though, as this is the second one-shot, possibly filler, issue we've had in a row since the crossover.  Well, ones that have certainly felt that way at least.  Nevertheless, this was well worth the 50p it cost in early '89.


Dave
Still, it allows the story to move back onto the Tombstone and Robbie Robertson trial.  I would say that this took a while to get going, but the Spidey and Carrion battle made it a better issue.



Kev
Oh, it definitely takes a minute to get going, yeh.  The entire first half of the issue is all set-up, but once it gets to where it's going, it's pretty much action all the way.


Dave
Gerry Conway is a seasoned veteran in this genre and knows how to build the overall story up in layers.  Plus, he cleverly keeps the sub-plots ongoing, so when one story is done, there is plenty more to move onto.


Kev
That was one of my favourite aspects of reading comics back in those days, was the way that so many writers, Conway prime amongst them, understood the serialised nature of comics and always planted seeds that had you wanting to come back for the next issue.


Dave
Yeah, it is very much an ongoing serial.  As you stated earlier, there are so many supporting characters, it helps to build this fictional world and give it more depth.

(D) & (K)

​Next: 'Guilty!'
Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Back issues

    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • HOME
  • About
  • Comic Reviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • Competitions
  • Contributors
  • Contact us